Old Fish House Restaurant

Extremely rude I believe she said her name was Kelly on the phone. Very short fused and upset me by insulting my intelli... Extremely rude I believe she said her name was Kelly on the phone. Very short fused and upset me by insulting my intelligence. Read more Read less

food, service are excellent.

Food is always fresh and delishous; Always!

Every time we come to town for a cruise, we plan out night around going here. The food is always excellent! They have... Every time we come to town for a cruise, we plan out night around going here. The food is always excellent! They have the best fried mushrooms I have ever eaten. They make their own ranch and blue cheese in house. Portions are generous. The prices are fair for the amount and quality of the food you receive. Read more Read less

Some of the fish is undercooked and clams were overcooked. Although the salad was good.

Family owned. Friendly. Cook came out of kitchen to discuss how fish was cooked

server was very helpful and provided great service

The atmosphere was unimpressive. The server was very busy and appeared to be worn out. She was not very pleasant and I f... The atmosphere was unimpressive. The server was very busy and appeared to be worn out. She was not very pleasant and I felt like she would not have cared whether we left or stayed. The manager did come over to ask how everything was but did not stay around long enough to hear what we had to say. The food was pricey but not bad. There were a steady flow of customers who seemed familiar with the restaurant which was a good thing. Read more Read less

The staff is the best part of the experience: friendly, sociable, owner came to table and interacted at length. The parr... The staff is the best part of the experience: friendly, sociable, owner came to table and interacted at length. The parrot fish was divine. The clams were just slightly overcooked. Read more Read less

I loved the curry dish I got. It was freshly made with great ingredients and really delicious.

I loved the curry dish I got. It was freshly made with great ingredients and really delicious.

Great family run restaurant. Delicious and consistent!

The food we ordered was well prepared and servings were generous. You could order small or large portions. The small po... The food we ordered was well prepared and servings were generous. You could order small or large portions. The small portions were large compared to most restaurants' standards. We ordered onion rings which were house prepared and delicious. Our waitress was attentive and efficient. Read more Read less

The food we ordered was well prepared and servings were generous. You could order small or large portions. The small po... The food we ordered was well prepared and servings were generous. You could order small or large portions. The small portions were large compared to most restaurants' standards. We ordered onion rings which were house prepared and delicious. Our waitress was attentive and efficient. Read more Read less

Generous portions, quality food, friendly staff. What else does one need?

Generous portions, quality food, friendly staff. What else does one need?

Generous portions, quality food, friendly staff. What else does one need?

Great salad but fish had too much batter for my liking

There was only one server. She was stressed and abrasive, although you could tell she did try to be nice, but was abras... There was only one server. She was stressed and abrasive, although you could tell she did try to be nice, but was abrasive most of the time. There are too many restrictions in place with the discount. The owner is strict and stingy with his policies and choices. The atmosphere is budget diner with the prices being high overall. Read more Read less

There was only one server. She was stressed and abrasive, although you could tell she did try to be nice, but was abras... There was only one server. She was stressed and abrasive, although you could tell she did try to be nice, but was abrasive most of the time. There are too many restrictions in place with the discount. The owner is strict and stingy with his policies and choices. The atmosphere is budget diner with the prices being high overall. Read more Read less

There was only one server. She was stressed and abrasive, although you could tell she did try to be nice, but was abras... There was only one server. She was stressed and abrasive, although you could tell she did try to be nice, but was abrasive most of the time. There are too many restrictions in place with the discount. The owner is strict and stingy with his policies and choices. The atmosphere is budget diner with the prices being high overall. Read more Read less

Had the red snapper blackened, Mahi Mahi blackened and deep fried Halibut. All were very good. Also the spicy clam chowd... Had the red snapper blackened, Mahi Mahi blackened and deep fried Halibut. All were very good. Also the spicy clam chowder was excellent Read more Read less

Had the red snapper blackened, Mahi Mahi blackened and deep fried Halibut. All were very good. Also the spicy clam chowd... Had the red snapper blackened, Mahi Mahi blackened and deep fried Halibut. All were very good. Also the spicy clam chowder was excellent Read more Read less

Service was excellent!! Owner came by and checked on us, but waitstaff was amazing and very attentive. Homemade Onion Ri... Service was excellent!! Owner came by and checked on us, but waitstaff was amazing and very attentive. Homemade Onion Rings and Fried Mushrooms were amazing, along with homemade sauces...some of best we've ever had! The fish was cooked perfect, loved the red skin potatoes and cole slaw, and platters are very filling. The only suggestion would be to put actual corn pieces in the corn fritters, because they didn't have any. We were wondering if they gave us hushpuppies by accident, but they said we had the corn fritters. Otherwise, all great!! Read more Read less

Yummy! We were in town and had tried it before. Remembering how good it was we went back & glad we did

They cook excellant. The food is always fresh. The atmosphere is so comfortable

It was a quaint fish house near the pier, my guest and I ordered the rock shrimp plate.

The best corn on the cob we’ve ever had at a restaurant. Crisp and flavorful. Excellent fried shrimp. The homemade key l... The best corn on the cob we’ve ever had at a restaurant. Crisp and flavorful. Excellent fried shrimp. The homemade key lime pie and chocolate cake were outstanding! Read more Read less

the owner/chef came and checked on the meal and we had a wonderful conversation with him about the fresh rock shrimp

I like that it’s laid back but the owner came out to chat with us.

The food is always excellent

The food is always excellent

Great food and service.

They were out of everything we selected from the menu, which was a big disappointment! So we just ordered several appeti... They were out of everything we selected from the menu, which was a big disappointment! So we just ordered several appetizers which amounted to $49. We were then told we had to purchase something else, even though they had NOTHING for one dollar, so we bought a cheese cake to take home, which cost $20. !!!!! Read more Read less

The food was good I brought left overs back and shared them 1 thing I did not like limits of what you can get

It's such a wonderful place to enjoy great seafood. They always have the best and are assured their customers are please... It's such a wonderful place to enjoy great seafood. They always have the best and are assured their customers are pleased with the food. Have loved going there for many years! Read more Read less

Food excellent

Sept 21 2016 Excellent in all great seafood and Service (Thanks Natascha) Chef also came out and we were very Impress... Sept 21 2016 Excellent in all great seafood and Service (Thanks Natascha) Chef also came out and we were very Impressed ! From chowder to shrimp,oysters, and fish were great!! Read more Read less

Our waitress (sorry I forgot her name :( ) was very efficient and friendly.

The food was mediocre, service was fair. Didn't feel like we were wanted or that they cares we were there.

The food was amazing!!! The service was even better!! Jessica was our server and she was excellent. Really made it... The food was amazing!!! The service was even better!! Jessica was our server and she was excellent. Really made it special. The only negative was my wine glass smelled AWFUL but she gave me a clean one for my wine no problems! The next thing we found at the end of our bottle of wine was something floating in my husbands glass. At this point we didn't want to make a big stink about it but forewarned them about checking the next bottles. Read more Read less

CHEF DIDN'T DO THE VOLCANO WITH THE STACKED ONIONS. ROOM TEMPERATURE WAS COLD.

Great service & flavorful food

It would have been nicer if the waitresses wore simple matching t shirts instead of skimpy tank tops that you wear to a... It would have been nicer if the waitresses wore simple matching t shirts instead of skimpy tank tops that you wear to a beach? Read more Read less

Service was slow, food was good. Stood up front for a couple minutes before anyone noticed us, then watched servers talk... Service was slow, food was good. Stood up front for a couple minutes before anyone noticed us, then watched servers talk on phone while we were ready & waiting to order. It was shift change, so that didn't help. Food was good though Read more Read less

The food was really good. One of the people in my group wanted to try the shrimp in their hot/spicy sauce and waitress c... The food was really good. One of the people in my group wanted to try the shrimp in their hot/spicy sauce and waitress came back and said that the chef/owner was making a new batch and it would not be ready in time for our dinner. The chef came out before we were done with a cup of the hot/spicy sauce for him to try. I thought that was excellent. Read more Read less